Is the future synthetic? E-fuels and the future energy system
I’ve previously talked about the challenges of finding an energy source for industries needing a source of concentrated energy such as aviation or even space flight. In my discussion I highlighted the challenges which batteries and hydrogen have with energy density and even suggested Ammonia as a possible alternative. There is one tantalising prospect which I haven’t yet addressed… synthetic fuels.
The premise of synthetic fuels is that a liquid hydrocarbon can be formed from either biomass or reacting Hydrogen with Carbon Dioxide. Currently alternative liquid fuels are generally biomass derivatives – it is however the fuels made from pure hydrogen, called e-fuels which provide an exciting prospect for decarbonising sectors which need a high-density source of energy.
The 2019 BP energy outlook puts global annual demand for transport fuels at just under 2000 million tonnes in 2035…. A gradual climb from the 1500 million tonnes consumed now. The lions share being taken up with trucks and around a third by aviation and marine transport. Trucks, Marine and Aviation present the biggest challenge to decarbonisation – as currently there is no scale-able green alternative primarily due the energy density of the alternate sources of energy currently available. It is this energy density challenge that e-fuels present a potentially exciting solution.
How are e-fuels made?
To make e-fuels you need plenty of pure Hydrogen and Carbon Monoxide. Carbon Monoxide is made through passing Carbon dioxide through the excitingly called ‘reverse water gas shift’ reaction which uses electricity to split up the Carbon Dioxide molecules. There are plenty of sources of carbon dioxide out there such as burning methane, coal or even biomass. The benefit of using that carbon dioxide in this process is it wouldn’t be released into the atmosphere or sequestered.
The hydrogen, required in large volumes, would be more costly to find. However, in a Hydrogen driven world the prospect of plentiful ‘Green’ hydrogen produced from offshore wind through electrolysis is the most hopeful source. Alternatively, both the hydrogen and the carbon dioxide could be obtained from steam blasting methane. Wherever the Hydrogen comes from the process is likely to be very energy intensive!
The final e-fuels process is called Fischer Tropsch. The process needs a catalyst such as cobalt, ruthenium or Iron. The feedstock of pure hydrogen and carbon monoxide is reacted with the catalyst in a chamber under pressure – the output being pure liquid hydrocarbon. This process generates a lot of heat so finding a home for that heat is important! It is this heat generation that makes the process quite inefficient as much of the energy available in the Hydrogen molecules is lost as heat. If this heat can be used, for example in an an industrial process or district heating then there is the opportunity to improve overall system efficiency.
Will e-fuels feature in the future?
Studies such as that by the Royal Society have put costs at around one and half euros a litre by 2050. However the price tag of four euros fifty a litre now really prices them out of the market!
In the event that legislation pushes trucks, aviation and marine to zero carbon then I believe that synthetic e-fuels will likely from part of the story. To what degree will depend on depth of decarbonisation and how competing technologies can push the energy density frontier. Additionally, human behaviour will impact demand for applications needing high energy densities – could road transport be shifted to electrified rail? Will there be less long haul travelling? For example.
Finally it is worth noting that the catalysts used in the process are hard to find and come with their own challenges. In particular cobalt mining has some important ethical considerations as does Nickel of which the ruthenium is a by-product. It seems as with battery technology that all pathways need thinking about to be sustainable and not just low carbon.
Photos Courtesy of Unsplash.
About John Armstrong
John Armstrong is an engineer whose career has spanned the extremes of the energy industry. He began his career constructing oil refineries before moving to work across fossil and renewable electricity generation. John has lead the growth of decentralised energy and district heating in the UK and is a seasoned energy infrastructure executive. John is a Fellow of the Institute of Mechanical Engineers, a member of the Energy Institute and has an MBA n Global Energy from Warwick Business School.